Understand the Differences between Sharecropping and Tenant Farming

14 Feb, 2023

Tenant farming is an agricultural production system in which landowners leased out their land to others, who don't have their lands; either on rent or free of cost without transferring the title of the land. Whereas, Sharecropping is a legal arrangement concerning agricultural land in which a landowner allows a tenant to use the land in return for a share of the crops produced on that land. There is no difference between tenant farming and sharecropping because sharecropping is one form of tenant farming.  To the extent that there is a difference, you can say that sharecropping is the form of tenant farming that is least beneficial to the tenant.

So, this article will differentiate between these two types of farming systems in India in 2023.

The agricultural sector is still considered an important part of the Indian economy because more than half of the Indian population relies on agriculture or farming for their livelihood. Agriculture and allied sectors in India contribute around 17 per cent to the country’s Gross Value Added (GVA). Since independence, there has been an increase in the population of India from a mere 36 crores in 1951 to 122 crores during the years 2010-11. However, the percentage of the rural population decreased steadily from  82.7 per cent to 68.9 per cent in the country. As per the statistics, out of the total working population, the country has 54.6 per cent agricultural workers and most of the rural population directly or indirectly relies on agriculture activities/occupations. 

As per the study of NSSO, tenancy reached from 6.6 per cent to 10.4 per cent in India during 2003-13. Andhra Pradesh (35.7 %), Bihar (22.7%),  Haryana (14.8 %), Odisha (16.9 %), Tamil Nadu (13.5 %) and West Bengal  (14.7 %) are a few states in terms of acreage under the tenancy. The majority of state governments in India restricted agricultural land leasing that forced insecure and informal tenancy without any legal sanctity. Tenant farmers are mostly marginal farmers and landless labourers who face problems during cultivation due to natural disasters like floods and droughts.  Even most of them are unable to get the benefits of subsidies and agricultural insurance which require land ownership documents.  

Thus, land is a scarce resource in 2023 and with increasing urbanization, tenancy-based agriculture is likely to increase in future.

So, without wasting much time let's learn to understand the differences between sharecropping and tenant farming in detail.

What is Sharecropping?

Sharecropping is one of the traditional cropping systems in India that involves both landowner's and farmer's resources. In this system, the landowner gives his land to any other farmers for a pre-decided time. The responsibility of the farmer is to cultivate the land and takes care of the farm by performing all the management practices. Finally, the yield obtained is then divided between the farmer and the landowner. The proportion the landowner receives is pre-decided. Generally, it stays between 40 to 60 per cent. In this case, both the farmer and the owner take the risk of harvest. The amount of harvest and all other fluctuations, including the price, will directly affect both the shares. Sharecropping has a long history and later it developed into different systems such as fixed tax and fixed crop rent systems.

In short, Sharecroppers farm on owners’ land and never own anything on their own as they are fully dependent on the landowners for the purchase of farming inputs and equipment. In return, the farmers have to pay input and equipment costs by exchanging the large portion of crops produced by them. This way, farmers get less benefit. 

Hence, the sharecroppers are the poor farmers who were unable to make a profit with crops produced as the cost of purchase was deducted from the earnings from crops sold.

What is Tenant Farming?

Tenant farming is a bit similar to sharecropping but has a more diverse meaning. Tenant farming is the system where a farmer rents land from the landowner for a certain period. And pay back in cash or a fixed portion of the farm output depending on the contract agreement between the farmer and the landowner. 

In short, Tenant is a farmer who involves in cultivation practices on another person’s land, by paying him rent, share, or tax. In tenant farming, the farmer lives in the same agricultural land or place for a given cultivation period. Normally, the farmers did not completely depend on landowners except for land and house, which they paid rent for them. Here, the farmers mostly bring the necessary equipment and inputs for the farm on their own. 

The landowner contributes to the cultivation by giving the land or sometimes providing the capital. Generally, The contract of tenant farming is either signed for a fixed year or tenancy at will. Since the farmers possess control over agricultural production, they have the right to decide on their harvested product and can even make small profits from crop production.

Difference Between Sharecropping And Tenant Farming

Conclusion

Thus, the understanding of differences between sharecropping and tenant farming shows that the landless farmers involved in farming as sharecroppers have less control over the crops produced and gets less benefit than the tenant farmers. On the other hand,  tenant farmers have full control over the crops produced and differ in dependency on the owners for purchasing inputs and equipment.  Moreover,  they possess the right to decide crop share and farming, and the benefits obtained from the earning of crop produced, which makes tenant farming better than sharecropping.

About TractorGyan

Tractor Gyan is an expert-led platform that aims to empower Indian farmers by providing accurate and timely information, and technological advancement about tractors and farm equipment in India.

TractorGyan helps farmers with New Tractor information, Compare Tractors, Tractor prices, Buying and selling of second-hand tractors, Tractor Insurance, Tractor Finance, Tractor tyre, Tractor Implements, Tractor EMI calculator and more. 

On our Platform, we have information about leading brands :

- In tractors like  New Holland, Preet, Farmtrac, John Deere

- In Tyres like BKT, Ceat, Apollo etc.

- In Tractor Loan/Finance like Kotak Mahindra Bank, Induslnd Bank, etc.

- In Tractor Implements like Kartar, Fieldking, Landforce, KMW, etc.

- In Tractor Insurance like Mahindra Finance, Axis Bank, ICICI Bank, etc.

TractorGyan is Helping India mechanise by delivering crucial information about tractor buying and guiding farmers at every step so that they get a tractor or farm equipment that empowers and equips them to produce quality yield.

FOLLOW US ON:- Facebook, Instagram, Linkedin